Welcome to Cogman’s Creek
At Cogman’s Creek, we bring the farm closer to your table. Our locally sourced meats are fresh daily, free from artificial growth stimulants, and processed close to home. Families, couples, and food enthusiasts enjoy our full-service deli and fast-casual atmosphere. Choose your favorite cuts, enjoy prepared foods, and experience traditional, sustainable farming that supports our local community.
From Farm to Deli
We take pride in sustainable farming and quality cuts. Our 300-acre family farm produces USDA Black Angus beef, free-range chicken, and organic pork. Every item in our butcher shop deli reflects care and tradition, with no antibiotics or artificial additives. Locals and visitors alike appreciate the honesty in our meats and prepared foods, offering meals that are fresh, flavorful, and responsibly raised.
Menu Highlights
Cogman’s Creek serves premium cuts, cold cuts, and farm-to-table prepared foods. Favorites include tender Black Angus steaks, juicy free-range chicken, and organic pork selections. Our full-service deli offers sandwiches, charcuterie, and sides made fresh daily. Whether stopping by for dine-in, takeout, or delivery, every meal showcases quality meats and ingredients sourced from our own farm.
Order with Ease
Skip the line and enjoy fresh farm-to-table meals at home. Cogman’s Creek delivers weekly provisions, lunch, and specialty meats right to your doorstep. Choose your preferred cuts, quantities, and delivery schedule to suit your needs. Our easy online ordering ensures you get the freshest meats without leaving home.
Fresh & Local
Experience the quality and care in every cut. Our gallery showcases premium meats, cold cuts, and prepared dishes made from our farm’s best.
Catering for Any Occasion
Cogman’s Creek brings farm-fresh meals to your next event. From corporate lunches to family gatherings, our catering includes hand-selected meats, sandwiches, and prepared dishes that impress guests. Every order is crafted with the same dedication to quality and locally sourced ingredients.
Fresh Groceries Delivered to Your Door
We offer local delivery within 10 miles of our store and weekly farm-fresh deliveries straight into Manhattan. Choose your favorite cuts, prepared foods, and seasonal ingredients, all sourced from our farm and brought directly to your home for convenience and quality you can trust.
What our guests are saying
Excellent local butcher and deli. I ordered 2 8oz filet mignons and the quality was excellent. Nice prepared foods and nice selection of frozen pastas. Highly recommend.
Chris C.
Great variety of very good meats. Can’t go wrong with their filet! Their daily specials are a must try. I usually go there a few times a week to grab one of their special sandwiches. Their broccoli cheddar bacon salad is amazing too.
Steve C.
The food was delicious and they couldn't have been any nicer! I asked them to make something that wasn't on the menu and they did an amazing job. Everyone loved it!
Andrea S.
Featuring
Delivery
Takeout
Dine In
Catering
Cogman’s Creek Rewards
Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online, and redeem your points for free food!
Frequently Asked Questions
What are you known for?
We are known for Wraps, Toast, New England Clam Chowder, Bacon, Avocado Toast, Chicken Sandwich, Lasagna, BBQ, Fries, Pancakes, Caprese Burger, Smokehouse Burger, Meatballs, Veggie Wrap, Chili, Sausage, Breakfast, Deli Sandwiches, Club Sandwich, Brisket, Soup, Caesar Salad, Cannoli, French Fries, Chili Burger, Cheese Steak, Onion Rings, Calamari, Catering, Salads, Chicken Wings, Ice Cream, BBQ Burger, Memphis Burger, Mozzarella Sticks, Classic Burger, Wings, Mac and Cheese, Chicken Caesar Wrap, Dessert, Panini, Eggs, BBQ Ribs, Cheesecake, Bruschetta, Apple Pie, Cheddar Burger, Cobb Salad, Caprese Salad, Buffalo Chicken Wrap, Tiramisu, Taylor Ham, Cookies, Caesar Wrap, Chicken Alfredo, Chicken Burger, Antipasto Salad, Chicken Wraps, Portobello Burger, Prosciutto, Burgers, Pizza, Greek Burger, Blt, Chicken Tacos, Breakfast Sandwich, Chicken Burgers, Burritos, Hot Dogs, Reuben Sandwich, French Toast, Pastries, Pizza Burger, Vegetarian Food, Gnocchi, Ravioli, Cheesesteak, Mashed Potatoes, Chicken Salad, Pasta, Pulled Pork, Grilled Chicken, Coleslaw, Clam Chowder, Caprese, Smash Burger, Sandwiches, and Fajitas
Where are you located?
We are located in Butler, NJ at 1376 NJ-23
What areas do you serve?
We serve the following areas: Butler, Apshawa, Smiths Mills, Kinnelon, Riverdale, Bloomingdale, Pompton Plains, Macopin, Pequannock, Pompton Lakes, Pompton, Wanaque, Charlotteburg, Pines Lake, Taylortown, Passaic County, Towaco, Echo Lake, Montville, Lincoln Park.
Our location
